.png)
Planning: choose the route to the home you need
Planning wrap-up · Episode 16
Tina Patel & Bart Kolosowski
Getting planning permission is a milestone. The useful question is whether it takes you towards a home you will actually enjoy.
Bart and Tina bring together their conversations with Aaron Zimmerman and Geoff Megarity, then test the choices behind the route, the application and the proposed start on site.
The expensive basement that nobody really used
Bart recalls homeowners who were determined to build a basement, worked through the complications and spent the money—then barely used the finished space.
The hosts do not argue that basements are always the wrong answer. They question starting with a fixed solution before understanding the need it is meant to meet.
A magazine image or a neighbour's project can spark an idea. Bring the underlying need to your designer as well: more useful living space, better light or a different way of using the house. Another solution may offer more value with less friction.
01
Define the need
Start with how you want to live.
02
Compare the routes
Weigh result, risk and time.
03
Read the decision
Review reasons or conditions.
04
Check readiness
Prepare before starting work.
Is the extra time worth the design you want?
Tina sees value in a planning strategy that takes longer but produces the preferred home. Bart brings the discussion back to the homeowner's choice: lay out the likely result, risk, cost and time for each route.
Their planning conversations revealed options that were not obvious at the outset, including using an available permitted development scheme as a fallback when seeking a different design.
The task is to compare those options clearly. A quicker route and a better result are not necessarily the same thing, but neither should additional applications become an aim in themselves.
Read the result before deciding what happens next
An approval needs to be read with its conditions. A refusal needs to be read with its reasons. Both can change the next task in the project, and neither should be reduced to a simple yes or no.
The hosts discuss how the officer's report can help the team identify changes after a refusal. Bart favours resubmission where the compromises are acceptable; Tina explains the work and uncertainty involved in an appeal.
Agree the next step with your advisers and your priorities in view. The point of understanding the process is to make a considered choice, rather than keep pursuing the original drawing simply because time has already been spent on it.
Judge progress by readiness, not by the first day on site
The strongest shared lesson from the guest conversations is to do the necessary preparation early. Bart connects this to construction: an early start with unresolved information can lead to waiting, changes and a later finish.
Tina asks homeowners to understand the purpose and timing of the reports their consultants recommend. Spending before construction can feel uncomfortable, but some of that work is what makes a sound application and a workable programme possible.
Ask what will be ready at each milestone. The useful target is a completed, usable home, with the information and approvals needed to get there—not simply an impressive start date.
Three decisions to take into your project
01 Keep the need separate from the solution.
Let your designer test alternatives before committing to a particular extension or basement.
02 Ask for a clear comparison.
Choose a planning strategy with its likely outcome, cost, risk and time explained.
03 Work towards a finished home.
Check the preparation and approvals behind the proposed start date.
The full conversation
Architect Tina Patel and quantity surveyor Bart Kolosowski wrap up our planning theme, drawing on the three preceding conversations with Aaron Zimmerman and Geoff Megarity.
They discuss planning routes in England, evidence, refusals, conditions and the homeowner's appetite for risk. Their own project examples bring the conversation back to choosing useful space and preparing for a smoother build.
Listen on Spotify · Apple Podcasts · Podbean
Explore a related episode
Episode 13: Planning permission: where do you start?
Revisit the starting decisions behind a planning application.
Episode 14: Permitted development: what can you build?
Check the opportunities and limits of permitted development.
Keep in touch
Get new episodes and useful podcast updates by email. Get email updates →